Cheddar cheese soup is a thick and creamy soup that is often prepared as an ingredient in other recipes. But cheddar cheese soup can also be served as a traditional soup and topped with croutons or broccoli.
Cheddar cheese soup is a common ingredient in fondus and sauces for meat and pasta. If you don’t know how to make cheddar cheese soup or don’t have condensed cheddar cheese soup at home, you’re probably wondering what can you use to substitute cheddar cheese soup in recipes.
So, what is the best cheddar cheese soup substitute? The best substitute for cheddar cheese soup is parmesan cheese soup. Parmesan cheese soup has a similar nutty flavor and smooth creamy texture as cheddar cheese soup. Other good substitutes for cheddar cheese soup are asiago cheese soup, nutritional yeast soup, and condensed cheddar cheese soup.
This article goes over the best substitutes for cheddar cheese soup and tells you how to use them in recipes instead of cheddar cheese soup.
What Is Cheddar Cheese Soup?
Cheddar cheese soup is a type of soup cooked using cheddar cheese as the main ingredient. It can be made using chunks, pieces, or shredded cheddar cheese.
Various additional ingredients including, milk, broth or stock, butter, heavy cream, onions, garlic, spices, and seasonings can be used to enhance the flavor of the soup.
Cheddar cheese soup has a smooth and creamy texture and is often used as an ingredient when preparing other dishes. It is commonly used in fondues, sauces for pasta, or prepared as a base for snack dips.
When served as a traditional soup, cheddar cheese soup is often topped with croutons. Ingredients like chopped bacon and chopped broccoli are sometimes used to enhance the flavor of cheddar cheese soup.
6 Best Cheddar Cheese Soup Substitutes
Cheddar cheese soup is a commonly used ingredient when preparing sauces for pasta and meat, fondues, and is also used as a base for dips. A number of soups have a similar flavor and texture as cheddar cheese soup and make a great cheddar cheese substitute in recipes.
1. Parmesan Cheese Soup
Parmesan cheese soup is the best substitute for cheddar cheese soup. It has a smooth and creamy texture similar to cheddar cheese soup and a nutty, sharp flavor.
Depending on the recipe, parmesan cheese soup is made from ingredients like milk, cream, grated parmesan cheese, onions, and seasonings. Parmesan cheese soup is quite thick and you can use it as a substitute for cheddar cheese soup when making sauces, dips, or fondues.
2. Asiago Cheese Soup
Asiago cheese soup is another good substitute for cheddar cheese soup. The main ingredient in this soup is asiago cheese, which is an Italian milk cheese that has a similar flavor to parmesan cheese.
There are many recipes for asiago cheese soup, but it’s often made from chicken stock, butter potatoes, wine, half and half, shredded asiago cheese, and veggies like garlic, onion, celery, and carrots. Eat asiago soup as a traditional soup or use it as a substitute for cheddar cheese soup in recipes.
3. Nutritional Yeast Soup
Nutritional yeast soup is an excellent substitute for cheddar cheese soup because it has a similar cheese and nutty flavor. This soup is just as creamy and smooth as cheddar cheese soup and can be used as a replacement in all recipes that call for cheddar cheese soup.
Nutritional yeast is a favorite vegan and vegetarian flavoring, making this soup a vegan-friendly substitute for cheddar cheese soup.
4. Condensed Cheddar Cheese Soup
Condensed cheddar cheese soup is a wonderful replacement for cheddar cheese soup when you’re in a pinch. This soup is meant to be used in any recipe that calls for cheddar cheese soup and can also be eaten as a traditional soup.
Condensed cheddar cheese soup can be purchased at most supermarkets. It has a very thick and creamy consistency that goes well with baked mac and cheese and cheese enchiladas.
5. Nacho Cheese Soup
Nacho cheese soup is a good substitute for cheddar cheese soup in all recipes. This creamy soup is made with milk, cheddar cheese, and spices.
Nacho cheese soup has a thick, creamy, and rich texture that is perfect for dips. Condensed nacho cheese soup is sold at most supermarkets and you can also make it at home using a few simple and readily available ingredients.
6. Black Olive Soup
Black olive soup is another suitable substitute for cheddar cheese soup. Unlike other cheddar cheese soup substitutes, black olive soup doesn’t taste like cheese.
Black olive soup has a thick and creamy texture that works well for meat and vegetable sauces and can also be served as a traditional soup.
Can I Substitute Cheddar Cheese Soup for Velveeta?
No, you can’t substitute cheddar cheese soup for Velveeta cheese in recipes. Although Velveeta cheese and cheddar cheese soup taste similar, they have completely different textures. However, you can substitute cheddar cheese in soup for Velveeta cheese.
Can You Substitute Cheddar Cheese Soup for the Cream of Chicken Soup?
Cheddar cheese soup isn’t the best substitute for cream of chicken soup. There are much better replacements for cream of chicken soup than cheddar cheese soup, including cream of mushroom soup, cream of celery soup, cream of shrimp soup, cream of potato soup, and cream of asparagus soup.
Cheddar cheese soup is a creamy, thick, and rich soup that is typically used as an ingredient in many other recipes. Although this soup is mostly used to make fondues, and creamy sauces for pasta and meat, it can also be served as a traditional soup.
If a recipe calls for cheddar cheese soup and you don’t have any at home, there are several substitutes you can use instead. Parmesan cheese soup is the best substitute for cheddar cheese soup. But you can also use asiago cheese soup, nutritional yeast soup, condensed cheddar cheese soup, black olive soup, nacho cheese soup, manchego cheese soup, and provolone cheese soup.